The modern merchant model
How a digital payment solution optimizes the procurement of travel services at the
Content
Outlook
6
Benefits of virtual credit cards for travel intermediaries
Benefits of virtual credit cards for end customers
What are virtual credit cards?
Why virtual credit cards are the payment solution for the merchant model
5
Merchant model: maximizing travel traffic
business models: merchant or agency
Comparison of travel intermediary
4
Indirect distribution: centered around travel retailing
The trend toward direct retailing
Who’s where in the travel trade ecosystem
ecosystem
How digitalization impacts the travel trade
3
The digitalization trend in B2B e-commerce
2
Introduction
1
¹
Travel is back in focus
Introduction
1
Global business travel and growth trend
³ 2022 BTI Annual Report and Forecast
² AirPlus C-suite survey results June 2021
However, weakening economic conditions in 2022 have slowed global recovery.Global business travel spending is expected to return to near pre-pandemic levels by 2025 at US$1.39 trillion. However, it’s not expected to surpass the US$1.4 trillion mark until mid-2026, when it’s forecast to reach US$1.47 trillion.
For business travel, 48% of respondents in a 2021 AirPlus survey predicted that, by 2024, their company’s business travel activity would rebound to an even higher level than in 2019, with 79% of these respondents citing the importance of personal interaction with customers and suppliers as a driver of this travel recovery.²
A boost in the confidence of leisure travelers has led to a growing intent to travel, with people having started planning for 2023 earlier.In the last quarter of 2022, 35% of all travel-related searches were for 2023 travel. - a 50% increase year-o year.
In this e-book, we’ll be exploring these questions. And since payment strategies play a central role in business success, we’ll analyze how and why virtual cards are a good fit for travel intermediaries to ensure smooth purchasing of travel services for
How has digitalization in e-commerce impacted the travel trade ecosystem? Which business model fits best for tackling the associated challenges and getting the most out of their retail business?
With the return of travel and the decline in the economy, digitalization is as important as ever. The trend toward online retailing has gained even more momentum since the pandemic – a time when the Internet was practically the only accessible environment.
Smarter payment. Better business
This is to say, external factors are not changing B2B purchasing, but rather the personas of the employees who manage procurement and purchasing processes today are changing and
Because of the changing demographics: Millennials and Gen Z will make up over 60%4 of the workforce by 2024. Both groups form the majority of today’s online B2C shoppers. Both Millennials and Gen Z use e-commerce to shop faster, get the best prices and discount offers, read customer reviews, and benefit from fast shipping.
Why?
Arguably the biggest game changer has been the consumerization of business-to-consumer (B2C) purchasing habits merging with the B2B ecosystem – a trend that will only increase over the next 5 years.
of the workforce in 2024 will consist of Millennials and Gen Z
> 60%
2
In recent years, the trend toward digitalization in the retail sector has been steadily increasing. In this chapter, we’ll be focusing on digital business-to-business (B2B) commerce by asking: What factors have driven the payment options in B2B e-commerce for direct (merchant-owned websites) and indirect (marketplaces) B2B e-commerce?
The digitalization trend in B2B e-commerce
4 Paypers Cross border payments and ecommerce report 2022-2023
Smarter payment. Better business
4
2
4
4
US$18 trillion
2018
US$22 trillion
2022
B2B e-commerce Gross Merchandise Value (GMV)
CAGR
Global
X%
17%
18%
US$41 trillion
2026
The coordinated process between the purchasing department and accounts payable to fulfill a need for goods or services in a timely manner and at a reasonable price.
Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR)
2022 – 2026
2018 – 2022
12%
24%
37%
11%
13%
18%
14%
25%
38%
15%
17%
19%
RoW
LATAM
North America
Middle East & Africa
Europe
APAC
Procure-to-pay defined
An estimated 80%4 of B2B buyers today are looking for a similar purchasing experience to that found on B2C websites.
Did you know?
Smarter payment. Better business
Will this growth simply be initiated by buyers? Not really. Suppliers are increasingly digitalizing their points of sales in the B2B space.
There is no doubt that the pandemic has led to on-site procure-to- pay processes being handled digitally and in a decentralized manner. But it won’t stop there: Forecasts expect B2B e-commerce volumes to exceed the US$40 trillion mark in 2026.
B2B e-commerce as a whole is growing fast and will further accelerate its growth with a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 16.5% between 2022 and 2026.
Buyers and vendors on both sides of the B2B ecosystem are taking proactive steps to enhance their digital presence, driving this growth.
This is a sensible strategy because, according to Forrester Research, 74% of B2B buyers today research online before making a purchase.
A survey by Vaimo found that, in 2022, 41% of surveyed B2B distributors plan to modernize their digital presence.
The travel trade ecosystem is made up of multiple layers and players, as illustrated in the schematic overview below. Several options for intermediaries are available for arranging bookings for end customers, consumers, or business travelers.
How digitalization is impacting the travel trade ecosystem
3
The increasing importance of digital presence in the B2B sector also affects the travel trade ecosystem, which encompasses buyers and vendors of travel services like travel agencies, online marketplaces, airlines, hotels, and other travel suppliers.
In this e-book, we focus on the heart of the travel trade ecosystem: Travel agencies and other retailers who act as intermediaries, purchasing from travel suppliers for resale and serving end customers or travelers. But before we zoom in on that, let’s take a bird’s eye view of the entire ecosystem and see who is positioned where.
Corporate traveler
Leisure traveler
Brand.com
Direct travel distribution channel
Meta search
Search
Travel supplier
Corporate traveler
Technical supplier¹ (e.g. GDS, Aggregators)
Tour Operator¹ (e.g. packaging)
Wholesaler¹ (e.g. bedbanks & consolidators)
¹ Some brands hold multiple roles
Intermediaries¹ (e. g. online & offline travel agency, tour operator, Brand.com, TMCs)
Leisure traveler
Indirect travel distribution channel
supplier
Travel
Smarter payment. Better business
ETTSA: The European Technology and Travel Services Association was established in 2009 to represent and promote the interests of global distribution systems (GDSs) and travel distributors to industry,
*
Hotel distribution costs, Infrata and EETSA, 2018
5
These options can be broadly divided into direct and indirect channels, with indirect channels such as offline and online agencies, travel management companies (TMCs) and tour operators using one or more intermediation layers between the end traveler and the supplier.
*
5
In a recent study by the European Technology and Travel Services Association (ETTSA ), 11 primary hotel distribution channels were identified. Airlines have similarly diverse options for selling inventory.
NDC
Lufthansa, British Airways, American Airlines, and Iberia were the first to adopt NDC, and the technology continues to make its way into airline distribution, alongside other means to improve airline operations. Currently, representatives from almost all airline distribution organizations have become involved with the NDC initiative in one way or another.
Access to customer data via NDC allows for better control of pricing strategies. An example of this is dynamic pricing, where various criteria are considered in real-time to enable truly personalized pricing.
The technical standards of the International Air Transport Association’s (IATA) form the basis of the new offer and order infrastructure. NDC is essentially an XML standard that enables airline service providers to deliver rich content and additional or ancillary services to their customers. Rich content is one of the factors through which airlines can market themselves and differentiate their brand.
3
Smarter payment. Better business
The model focuses on transforming traditional systems and processes into a modular IT infrastructure that is better suited for retailing travel products. Future orders made through this system will be able to include multiple supplier and product records in one order instead of today’s fragmented booking and ticketing record system.
For airlines to become modern (read: digitalized) and empower travel retailers to offer their customers the flexibility to optimize, personalize and monetize their products, the airline industry has introduced the ‘offers and orders’-based model.
The application of digitalization in airlines also serves as proof of how digital direct retailing has impacted the travel industry. We start with the fundamental understanding that all airlines, as providers of travel services, share two basic needs: revenue and passenger satisfaction.
Customer expectations continue to evolve, and leading consumer brands are now focused on providing optimized digital experiences. An example of this can be seen with Betterment, a financial advisory company that delivers investment advice directly to users through its intuitive mobile app, and the global technology company Samsung, which uses artificial intelligence (AI) to improve online customer support.
Direct booking channels, on the other hand, are typically used more when, for example, a strong airline or hotel chain is present in the market as a travel service provider or when the focus is on domestic travel. And as the term ‘direct’ implies, the emphasis is on the end customer – without involvement of intermediaries.
The trend toward direct retailing
However, it goes without saying that the digitalization taking place in B2B e-commerce is also having a big influence on how these businesses interact with customers.
Smarter payment. Better business
To avoid being left out and truly reach and influence travelers and travel managers in how they shop, book and purchase travel, providers like online travel agencies (OTAs), travel management companies (TMCs) and leisure travel agencies must participate in this process. That said, with the future lying in retail, intermediaries – many of which are inherently travel sellers – already hold a key position in travel distribution
Indirect distribution: centered around travel retailing
As airlines and travel service providers are an undeniable part of the travel ecosystem, the customer-centric focus of the NDC in this more personalized approach also has direct implications for intermediaries within the ecosystem.
Meta search
Search
supplier
Travel
Corporate traveler
(e.g. GDS, Aggregators)
Technical supplier¹
(e.g. packaging)
Tour Operator¹
consolidators)
(e.g. bedbanks &
Wholesaler¹
TMCs)
Brand.com,
tour operator,
agency,
offline travel
(e. g. online &
Intermediaries¹
Leisure traveler
Indirect travel distribution channel
3
Smarter payment. Better business
Providing an enhanced booking experience for customers by bundling trips, enabling multiple trip components, cross-selling and up-selling within a single booking journey.
Helping to fill capacity and shift inventory for airlines and hotels by generating additional demand as travel intermediaries.
Extended reach for travel suppliers into more geographic markets and segments than would normally be accessible to them. Travel intermediaries often have greater local brand awareness and the ability to serve customers in remote markets where they have a deep knowledge of local needs and regulations, such as consumer protection and refund obligations.
Providing efficient after-sales support to customers, such as handling changes to complex itineraries involving multiple travel suppliers or even just multiple flight segments. Mass rebookings and cancellations during the pandemic increased this need, as many airlines lack sufficient resources to manage this process alone.
3
They can secure their position by leveraging a wide range of benefits for hotels, airlines and other travel providers. These include:
Smarter payment. Better business
These benefits can be further enhanced through fraud reduction and improved payment management when travel intermediaries use the merchant model – a set-up in which they hold the lead in the relationship with both their suppliers and customers.
After all, as mentioned above, travel intermediaries create value for their partners by extending reach, driving demand, and growing sales.
It’s also worth noting that large OTAs have greater marketing budgets and reach than global hotel chains and major airline groups. The power of these marketing engines brings more demand and volume to travel suppliers who choose to work with these travel agencies.
6
In addition, the largest online travel agencies (OTAs) in the travel distribution ecosystem have become so important that, pre-Covid, the top players each handled annual travel volume in the order of US$100 billion, surpassing the major airlines in revenue.
Comparison of marketing and advertising spend
(Annual US$, pre-Covid)
Large airline group
Global online travel agency
Global hotel chain
US$5.0B+
US$1.0B
US$0.5B
Smarter payment. Better business
Travel intermediaries can be classified in one of two business models: merchant or agency. What are the differences?
Comparison of travel intermediary business models: merchant or agency
4
With the ‘merchant model’, the travel agency accepts the booking and handles the payment from the end traveler, making it the merchant of record for the incoming consumer payment and therefore needing to make separate outgoing payments to each supplier involved in the booking.
In the ‘agency model’ or ‘pass-through’ model, the travel intermediary accepts the booking but does not handle the payment from the end traveler. For hotel bookings, this typically means that the end traveler pays the hotel directly upon arrival or at check-out. And for flight bookings, the travel agency passes the end traveler’s credit card information to the airline.
Smarter payment. Better business
The expectations of end travelers have changed over the past ten years. In addition to the digitalization element of online purchases, another factor has been the development of new payment methods. Many travel intermediaries have had to adapt to a digital, more comprehensive retail concept to meet these new expectations. This, in turn, has necessitated even greater use of the merchant model to offer
Merchant model: maximizing travel traffic
As mentioned above, travel intermediaries are well positioned in the market, holding the key both as buyers of travel supplier services and as sellers of those services to their end customers. By maximizing this position, they can remain firmly embedded in the ecosystem.
The following is an overview of the advantages of the merchant model over the traditional agency model:
4
• Limited control
• Reconciliation complexity
• No insight into payment flows
• Confusing card billing statements
• Unpredictable pricing
• Lack of data security
costs
• Potential savings by avoiding multiple separate charges FX
through payment
• Convenience of a single point of contact, from booking
• Flexibility to use their preferred payment method
• Security, as only the agency handles payment information
The agency passes the traveler’s card information to the suppliers, who settle the payment directly with the consumer. Among the drawbacks:
Pass-through model
The travel agency accepts and processes the customer’s payment. It then initiates payments to the various suppliers associated with the trip. Both consumers and the travel agency benefit from this in several ways.
Merchant of Record (MoR) model
• Enhanced cash flows as customer payments go directly into the agency’s bank account
• Profit potential through commissions and rebates
• Greater control over consumer experiences
• Financial protection through transparency of B2B payment flows and clear network rules
For travel agencies
For customers
Smarter payment. Better business
6
Smarter payment.Better business
4
Where did the preference for the merchant model start?
However, even in the 1980s, hotel bookings were made almost exclusively through the agency model, and customers expected to pay for their stay at the accommodation. This began to change with the founding of the Hotel Reservations Network in 1991. The company was a hotel-focused travel agency accepting bookings through toll-free numbers and reportedly “spending 90% of [their] time as a collection agency and
To answer this, we only need to focus on airline bookings, as they have a long history of using the merchant model. This includes the IATA BSP, which was introduced in 1971.
The original goal of the merchant model – to eliminate commission collection effort – changed over time to enable, deliver, and maximize a range of other benefits.
The founders believed something had to change and approached hotels with an offer to buy inventory at a net price up front, then resell it to travelers at a gross price. The former Dorset Hotel in Manhattan was the first to officially sign up. The Hotel Reservations Network was acquired by USA Networks in 1999, becoming Hotels.com. It was joined by Expedia, which was acquired by USA Networks in 2001. Both companies focused on the merchant model, and Expedia eventually launched the merchant model for hotel bookings in Europe during its expansion in the early 2000s.
Virtual credit cards are the ideal solution for centrally controlling and managing B2B supplier expenses.
.
It’s essential for travel intermediaries to have access to B2B paymentoptions to ensure that the benefits also flow through to both the travelsuppliers and the end customer. With the right B2B payment options, they can weigh the risks and costs of their activities as merchants of record. Without such options, these risks and costs go on to impact both travel suppliers and end customers
An effective strategy for B2B supplier payments can be just as important for travel intermediaries as their payment strategy toward their end customers when operating the merchant model, as they occupy a central position between the customer and the supplier.
®
Powered by Mastercard
Expiry date
Card Verification Code (CVC)
Card number
Let’s take a closer look at what exactly virtual credit cards are all about. A virtual credit card is a 16-digit card number with a three-digit CVC code generated specifically for individual purchases. It can be a Mastercard® number, for example. Importantly, the card number loses its validity once it has been used.
What are virtual credit cards?
5
Why virtual credit cards are the payment solution for the merchant model
Virtual credit cards, designed specifically as a B2B payment solution for travel trade, are a crucial enabler in maximizing the benefits and adoption
Smarter payment. Better business
The intermediary therefore receives a single statement instead of many individual invoices and has only one supplier: the virtual card provider.
Each card number can be restricted to a specific booking and set to a specific amount, validity period, and currency. This ensures that virtual cards for travel trade businesses are both secure and flexible, especially for the intermediary’s booking agents, who handle multiple payments across numerous channels every day. Mastercard’s virtual credit cards also protect travel retailers against losses due to supplier default.
Extremely secure
All transactions made with virtual credit cards within a specified period are typically consolidated by the provider into a single, easy to understand statement and issued to the intermediary at the end of an agreed statement period. Suppliers, on the other hand, immediately receive payment from the provider.
Combined billing
instead of multiple
individual invoices
7
Virtual credit card these are its characteristics
By generating a virtual credit card number from the Mastercard® network, travel retailers can pay for all their travel services worldwide. For some perspective, the Mastercard network currently includes 80 million acceptance points worldwide – all providers in this network would accept virtual Mastercard cards.
High acceptance
Smarter payment.Better business
Advantages of virtual credit card for end customers
Under the merchant model, bundling individual trip components is smoother and easier with virtual cards for supplier payments. Customers can tailor their travel experience more effectively by offering a much wider range of options. The enhanced experience continues at check-out, as the end customer is billed only one amount for their trip, avoiding disparate charges from multiple suppliers.
Using the merchant model with virtual credit cards for B2B payments enables travel intermediaries to build on the core benefits for end customers, with even more choice, better bundling, and less friction at check-out.
Smarter payment. Better business
Acceptance of these options by travel intermediaries ensures a smoother check-out experience for end customers. Travel intermediaries may be more willing to make the necessary investments for accepting these payment options and controlling fraud risks when they know they can easily make outgoing payments to travel suppliers using virtual credit cards – especially as they simplify their own payment operations.
Travel intermediaries are well placed to accept a variety of locally preferred payment options from their customers, which may be unique to their local jurisdictions or simply driven by local preferences. These can include different currencies or payment methods, such as bank transfers, credit cards, ‘Buy Now Pay Later’ (BNPL), and pre-payment installments.
In addition to the provided payment options, pricing is also (primarily) managed by the travel intermediary. This makes bundling, cross-selling, and up-selling easier in a merchant model. The wide variety of additional options, and demand generated via such offers, can deliver better value
The ability to choose which currencies and payment types they accept from end customers enables them to effectively screen incoming payments for fraud.
Travel intermediaries opt for the merchant model because, in addition to the better customer experience already mentioned, it allows them to increase their volume and leverage their capabilities in handling customer payments.
5
• A virtual credit card solution for travel trade combines credit lines and payment terms to significantly improve cash flow
• Digital statements include all the necessary information for reconciling transactions and invoices, enriched with additional data in an easy-to-read overview
Managing and controlling these two elements can be a major challenge for many travel retailers. Virtual credit cards help to address these issues as follows:
This already relieves the financial pressure on the travel intermediary’s business. In general, the financial pressure travel intermediaries face in their payment processes revolves around reconciling payment transactions and supplier invoices and securing cash flow.
Suppliers in this chain also benefit as there’s no need for them to accept the same payment combinations: virtual credit card payments effectively provide them with a payment guarantee.
Advantages of virtual credit cards for travel intermediaries
Smarter payment. Better business
Direct retailing by airlines, which personalizes their service offerings in direct relationships with their customers, is affecting the intermediaries at the center of this same ecosystem. They strive to maintain their indispensable role as retailers and persuade travel suppliers to rely on their expertise to extend their reach, boost demand, and increase sales.
The pandemic has again demonstrated the value of indirect distribution and travel retailing through the merchant model for travel intermediaries, travel suppliers and, ultimately, endcustomers. This includes crisis management and adaptation to changes in consumer behavior and buying preferences.
The merchant model is most beneficial for maintaining the balance within the ecosystem. It supports the optimal use of payment methods with greater choice for the end customer. At the same time, the travel intermediary – working closely with travel suppliers – can acquire travel services using virtual credit cards to enable optimized cash flow and smooth payment processes. This practice at the heart of the ecosystem impacts the entire travel value chain.
Smarter payment. Better business
6
Digitalisation in B2B e-commerce is here to stay – something that also impacts the travel trade ecosystem. Along with the digitalisation trend, the pandemic and the subsequent recovery of the travel industry forced a further re-evaluation of business models and payments.
The modern merchant model
Outlook
airplus.com/contact
AirPlus International
Do you have any questions? Feel free to contact us!