Case study: Optimizing processes at ZE Friedrichshafen AG
The planners research venues, compare hotel offerings, and initiate the payment process. After the event, staff members in accounting have to reconcile the diverse receipts in connection with the event and often they must take into consideration various types of invoices and the diverse ways the charges are displayed. These steps tie up resources. What are the options to simplify the process?
Managing business conventions, customer events and / or incentive trips is extremely time-consuming. Successful event management depends on the planners having good organizational skills and on the downstream processes in the accounting department, that is, the interplay between planning and accounting.
Case study: Optimizing processes at ZF Friedrichshafen AG
Event management study
* MICE stands for the broad field of event management that includes the organization of meetings, incentives, conventions and events.
Be it meeting planners or accounting staff – every person involved in the process benefits greatly from the introduction of a MICE tool with optimized payment processes to be used in conjunction with the AirPlus Meeting Card.”
Automotive supplier ZF Friedrichshafen AG was highly satisfied with the result. Annette Trautmann is responsible for the company’s travel management. She says: “The potential for improvement in all the steps of our process exceeded our expectations.
The combination of AirPlus Meeting Card and hotel portal put to the test
The results were remarkable:
The processing time the event planners needed was reduced from almost eleven hours to just over four hours per meeting – a more than 60 percent reduction! In the accounting than 60 percent reduction! In the accounting than 60 percent reduction! In the accounting department, the time spent per event was cut back 68 percent to eight minutes instead of 25.
How much time can a company actually save when using the AirPlus Meeting Card together with a hotel portal?
At the request of AirPlus International, business consultants at Steinberg & Partner GmbH conducted a trial at ZF Friedrichshafen AG, a leading global driveline and chassis technology group.
The first parameter to be captured was the time ZF Friedrichshafen AG was spending on managing its events. This parameter then was juxtaposed with the potential savings the company would achieve through the use of the AirPlus Meeting Card and a hotel portal as a booking platform.
Instead, they can be bundled on the AirPlus Meeting Card and aggregated in one invoice. This collective invoice outlines all expenses incurred.
The principle is this: The hotel portal facilitates faster searching and comparisons of hotels. Once the event planner has opted for a venue, the invoices no longer need to be settled individually or reconciled.
Combining an online tool with a universal payment solution can streamline the entire process significantly and also save time. One option is to use a hotel portal in combination with the AirPlus Meeting Card.
New process optimization options
2
ter business.
Smarter payment. Bet
the individual steps in the process. Because the time needed varies depending on the type of meeting or event, the authors of the study defined ten event types. Then they calculated average values for the time required to process an event.
As part of the study, Steinberg & Partner GmbH determined how much time event planners and accounting staff spent on
Steinberg & Partner GmbH used the supplier revenues generated at six of ZF Friedrichshafen AG’s sites for the study’s empirical foundation. Additional data was collected in interviews with travel managers, event planners and accountants.
Fundamentals of the study
less than 50 participants
29 %
50 – 100 participants
49 %
over 100 participants
22 %
percentage of events attended by the respective number of participants
Basis of the study:
Size of event and distribution
3
ter business.
Smarter payment. Bet
Event planning starts with the question of which hotel is worth considering for the occasion at hand. The event planner will use the Internet and / or colleagues’ recommendations or relevant print media to compare hotels and decide on a match. This research used to take an average of approximately 90 minutes per event. Hotel portals have sped up the process significantly because they provide straightforward access to all hotels and thus reduce research time to about 30 minutes on average
1. Research
The key results of the study reveal themselves when you look at each step separately: How much time can be saved in which steps? The results can provide ZF Friedrichshafen AG with valuable information. In the report on the results of the study, time savings were shown both as a percentage and in absolute numbers.
The results in detail
At ZF Friedrichshafen AG, conventions and meetings typically are planned by the experts in the units responsible. Frequently, the processes assessed for the study including conducting research, finding the ideal convention hotel and reviewing invoices, are managed by the event planners in addition to their regular responsibilities. Using a hotel portal in combination with the AirPlus Meeting Card helps event planners complete these steps more easily and quickly.
Event planning
Potential savings: 63 %
4
Smarter payment. Better business.
5
ter business.
Smarter payment. Bet
Making inquiries online directly via a hotel portal generally takes less time and allows event planners to at least cut in half the time they used to spend on research on average.
2. Inquiry
Potential savings: 50 %
Hotel portals also offer a large variety of functions that help planners make their decisions for or against a hotel, for example, by generating documents automatically. Today, ZF Friedrichshafen AG’s event planners only need eight minutes to make their decisions regarding venues and the time they save is an impressive 85 percent.
4. Decision
Potential savings: 85 %
The next step is for the event planner to select the right offer. On average, ZF Friedrichshafen AG’s planners spent close to 90 minutes on this task per event. Hotel portals also have proven to be efficient aids with this task: The automatic program comparison function clearly juxtaposes the hotels selected with the added bonus that at anytime event planners can see whether a given hotel has processed the inquiry.
3. Handling offers
Potential savings: 65 %
ZF Friedrichshafen AG specifies the terms of booking and submits them to the hotels along with the inquiry. The company enters into a contract with a hotel when it accepts the offer the hotel makes in the portal. The terms of booking become part of the contract automatically. In general, ZF Friedrichshafen AG no longer is required to make deposits – thanks to the AirPlus Meeting Card – and therefore has minimized its financial processes and saves a great deal of time.
5. Contract
Potential savings: 96 %
Steps to be followed in hotel portals using the AirPlus Meeting Card
Booking portal
Reviewing the invoice
Making changes
Signing the contract
Deciding on a hotel
Handling offers
Inquiries
Research
AirPlus Meeting Card
Payment
Booking
Reviewing the invoice
Changing the number of participants or canceling parts of an event also costs time and money. For ZF Friedrichshafen AG it turned out that on average almost 25 percent of the time and money used for planning was spent on implementing such changes. Hotel portals help reduce this time by a third.
6. Changes
Potential savings: 33 %
Potential savings: 62 %
The great advantage here is that an initial invoice review is conducted in the hotel portal and a structured statement is provided to the event planner for review. Any necessary approvals of unexpected invoiced amounts can be mapped in the tool. Invoiced amounts are not settled in the portal through AirPlus International until the event planner has confirmed every item listed on the statement. This process renders correcting invoices obsolete.
7. Invoice review
6
ter business.
Smarter payment. Bet
Processing hotel invoices is more time-consuming for accounting staff than processing other types of receipts because the layout of hotel invoices is less transparent, the number of creditors is large, and extensive approval and documentation processes are required. The AirPlus Meeting Card can simplify the accounting process substantially.
Booking and paying
Rather than having to review every receipt separately, customers paying with the AirPlus Meeting Card are provided with all the required details in one AirPlus-issued invoice. In addition, AirPlus’ schematized invoice layout simplifies the allocation of expenses to accounts. This helps ZF Friedrichshafen AG save approximately four minutes (39 percent). Time-consuming inter- mediate steps such as repeatedly requesting lists of participants are omitted entirely. As opposed to other companies, ZF Friedrichshafen AG does not allocate detailed meeting costs to multiple general ledger accounts; if it did, it could save even more time.
2. Booking
Potential savings: 39 %
1. Invoice receipt
On average, ZF Friedrichshafen AG’s
accounting department spent
almost ten minutes to process each
invoice issued by a hotel for
a convention. For example, each
invoice had to be reviewed for
accuracy and then scanned. These
steps quickly add up if there
are many invoices to process. In
contrast, customers using the
AirPlus Meeting Card are issued one
collective invoice that is uniform
and standardized yet contains every
detail about every event. This
not only facilitates transparent and
efficient analyses, it also saves
time: ZF Friedrichshafen AG reduced
the time spent on these steps by
93 percent!
Potential savings: 93 %
Fewer invoices, faster reviews: The collective invoice issued by AirPlus also significantly reduces the number of affected payment runs. ZF Friedrichshafen AG had automated its payment processes to a degree that the actual time saved barely carried weight. Yet, during the trial the company achieved a 75 percent saving of time.
3. Payment
Potential savings: 75 %
7
Smarter payment. Better business.
Steinberg & Partner GmbH
Rüdiger Mahnicke,
the amount of time saved processing the various event types.”
“As business consultants we were fascinated to see
Potential savings: 100 %
The study was based on the assumptions that every year ZF Friedrichshafen AG’s accountants check one hundred times to determine whether they need to create new creditors in the system and that only 50 new suppliers actually have to be created every year. These numbers then were broken down to the number of events. The time savings were huge: The entire process can be eliminated because AirPlus is the only creditor.
4. Creating creditors in the system
Potential savings: 100 %
Payment reminders no longer need to be processed because AirPlus pays the hotels in advance. The authors of the study assumed that a customer such as ZF Friedrichshafen AG otherwise would have to process 100 reminders every year.
5. Processing reminders
8
ter business.
Smarter payment. Bet
in decimal hours
Event planning
in industrial minutes
Posting and payment of event bill
9
Smarter payment. Better business.
Facts & figures on event management
ZF allows vehicles to see, think and act. In the four technology domains ofZF is a global technology company supplying systems for passenger cars, commercial vehicles and industrial technology, enabling the next generation of mobility. ZF allows vehicles to see, think and act. In the four technology domains of Vehicle Motion Control, Integrated Safety, Automated Driving, and Electric Mobility, ZF offers comprehensive product and software solutions for established vehicle manufacturers. With some 165,000 employees worldwide, ZF reported sales of € 43.8 billion in fiscal 2022. The company operates 168 production locations in 32 countries.
ZF is a global technology company supplying systems for passenger cars, commercial vehicles and industrial technology, enabling the next generation of mobility.
ZF Friedrichshafen AG
AirPlus International is a leading international provider of corporate payment solutions. 53,000 corporate customers rely on AirPlus for the payment and evaluation of their business trips and other purchasing services. The products and services are marketed worldwide under the AirPlus International brand. The AirPlus Meeting Card is part of AirPlus’ extensive portfolio of solutions for managing costs.
AirPlus International
Steinberg & Partner GmbH’s team of highly specialized business consultants has been supporting clients with procurement and process optimization for business travel since 1994. In the MICE segment, Steinberg & Partner GmbH has implemented end-to-end process solutions for meetings and other purposes for renowned companies across industries.
Steinberg & Partner GmbH, Hamburg
Steinberg & Partner GmbH
Rüdiger Mahnicke,
the accounting department, receipts already will have been approved and pre-allocated to an account and all documents related to an event will be complete.”
“ZF Friedrichshafen AG is open to the introduction of a portal and the AirPlus Meeting Card. The finance departments in particular will benefit enormously from the controlled flow of receipts and approvals that will come with the introduction of these tools: By the
10
ter business.
Smarter payment. Bet
Savings per event
43 – 48 %
Potential savings:
59 %
Potential savings:
73 %
Potential savings:
Potential savings:
€ 438 – 488
Process savings / costs
Savings per event
**
€ 50 – 100
*
Booking function, invoice review and expenses settled by AirPlus
Meeting platform costs
€ 432.92
€ 301.78
€ 734.70
Balance
€ 79
€ 79
€ 79
Hour factor
5.48 h
3.82 h
9.30 h
Hours spent per event
Savings
Target process
Current process
Meeting platform savings
€ 105.07
€ 37.92
€ 142.99
Balance
€ 79
€ 79
€ 79
Hour factor
1.33 h
0.48 h
1.81 h
Hours spent per event
Savings
Target process
Current process
AirPlus Card savings
Ralph Rettig, Travel Manager ZF Group
“The study has opened our eyes to the large potential of optimizing our MICE processes. Going forward, structured planning, booking, and payment processes will provide us with the level of transparency we desperately need in this segment. In addition, we will benefit from better cooperation with the hotel sector.”
EN, 07.24, CL
airplus.com/contact
AirPlus International
Do you have any questions? Feel free to contact us!